If you want to continue using the old site, you still can here.
  • Favorites
  • Print
  • Rate Me

preaching article A Dozen Ways to Kill a Great Idea

A Dozen Ways to Kill a Great Idea

based on 4 ratings
May 23, 2013
Scripture: none
(Suggest Scripture)

Ever watched a really good idea crash and burn? Me too.

Here’s some brutal honesty: Entire movements have gone down in flames because of boneheaded approaches to good ideas. This isn’t to say we can’t afford to make mistakes. In fact, the only way to know we’re taking risks is to make mistakes. We can’t afford not to make them. But we also can’t afford to ignore timeless principles of leadership effectiveness.

In honor of our most fatal leadership mistakes, here are my “from the hip” ways to kill great ideas. (Warning: sarcasm ahead)

1. Form a committee. In this way, you’ll be able to devote more time to keeping minutes and electing officers and less time to solving problems. Also, we’ll be able to prevent a single great leader from running with the idea without feeling the need to check with several people with different opinions before proceeding.

2. Be sure to control it. Before you even start executing a good idea, be sure to write plenty of rules and parameters so that no one feels the freedom to run too fast with it. Freedom is the enemy when we’re trying to kill good ideas.

3. Devote a lot of time to calculating the costs. Be sure that everyone understands just how much failing can cost us so that we inch along, paralyzed by fear.

4. Assume it’s everyone’s responsibility. If we’re able to say, “Our church should really be doing this,” it takes the pressure off anyone in particular who might actually take ownership. In this way, no one gets blamed for the death of the idea ... at least not individually.

5. Assume it’s your responsibility alone. If we get help, we’ll just saddle people with the burden of investing their time into meaningful pursuits rather than having more free time to not develop their gifts for kingdom influence.

6. Vote on it. This will give everyone a sense of power and let them decide that they’re “against” the idea even if it isn’t something they understand. After all, majorities of people are usually smart, right? Besides, in the end, it’s really about keeping as many people as possible happy.

7. Avoid learning from others who have acted on similar ideas. Never ask people who have succeeded or failed before. It’s better to re-invent the wheel, take full credit (or blame) in the end and brag on how much we’ve been able to do (or not do) all on our own.

8. Keep young people out of it. They’re all too inexperienced and unwise to lead anything. Besides, do the voices of the young really matter? I thought they were meant to be seen and not heard ... or valued.

9. Keep old ... advanced ... experienced people out of it. After all, they’re just all grumpy, afraid of change and set in their old-fashioned ways. Their years of wisdom and experience will just complicate matters.

10. Keep women out of it. In all honesty, even in sarcasm, I’m too afraid to touch this one. I can just testify it’s boneheaded.

11. Execute the idea purely in our natural power. God’s power is just too much. The Holy Spirit can’t even be seen visibly, especially at committee meetings. Besides, we need to be busy executing, not wasting time in prayer.

12. Take a little more time to talk about your intentions for the good idea. As long as you’re intending to do something good, it’s as good as doing it, except that it never gets done. But you will have meant well when it’s all said and not done.

I’m guilty of at least a majority of these at one time or another in my own leadership, so I’m not writing out of arrogance but in confession.

Brandon Cox is lead pastor of Grace Hills Church, a new church plant in northwest Arkansas. He also serves as Editor and Community Facilitator for Pastors.com and Rick Warren's Pastor's Toolbox and was formerly a pastor at Saddleback Church in Lake Forest, California. In his spare time, he offers consultation to church leaders about communication, branding and social media. He and his wife Angie live with their two awesome kids in Bentonville, Arkansas.

Talk about it...

Clarence Bolton avatar
Clarence Bolton
0 days ago
You wouldn't be Baptist would you?
David Tompkins avatar
David Tompkins
0 days ago
forming a committee in itself is not really the problem. Including many unnecessary and problematic people is. Some people just love to derail a project. Great article!
Dale Fitch avatar
Dale Fitch
0 days ago
Great ideas. I wholeheartedly agree. Especially when it involves VISION. The quickest way to kill a Vision is to share it prematurely. But when you are sure it is from God, go for it. Great article appreciate your sharing
Mark Pittman avatar
Mark Pittman
0 days ago
Okay, I get this. Heck, I've lived this. But it doesn't sound at all like the kingdom and body Jesus talks about. Since he started this (dare I say"mess") doesn't Jesus say anything about how to lead and create a group of Jesus-followers who would reject such behavior? (He does.) Maybe we leaders are guilty of not following our Rabbi when we expect and tolerate such in our midst. I am tired of hearing "Well, as pastor you can't really say this." Really? This kind of community is what I call people to? Sorry, my Jesus bought me something much better than that...no cynicism intended. I once heard Paul Borden say, "If you are afraid of losing your job for the sake of the kingdom, you are not worthy of the title 'Pastor.'" Yes! I love these people so much that I am willing to lose my job for them. I'm not talking about exerting my power here. There is another whose power changes lives and hearts. Brandon, I really do get this. After some 30 years in ministry, I am tired of playing church. Follow Jesus and love each other, really!
Rene Tancongco avatar
Rene Tancongco
0 days ago
I would like to add the following: (1) What kills is when committee members don't have the gifting required for the task, (2) Team leaders do not know how to handle meetings professionally turn 1 hr meetings into 3 hrs, and(3) Over-analyze: death by analysis.

So, what did you think?


Thank you.