In Part 1 of this two-part series, I offered ten commandments for biblical preaching. I stand by the convictions that I expressed in that essay and believe those commandments have something to offer biblical preachers. But some rules also are meant to be broken.
The art of preaching can be compared to the art of musical performance. Music operates according to sets of conventions: the musical key, the time signature, the musical genre, the instrumentation. To play music, a musician has to know and understand these conventions and play within them.
But sometimes music becomes even more creative when someone intentionally breaks the rules, such as when someone adds "more cowbell," as it were, or when Beethoven introduced a full chorale into a symphony, or when Bill Monroe married primal vocal harmonies to an up-tempo string ensemble, or when Leo Fender and Les Paul separately wired electric pickups onto solid pieces of wood.
In each of these cases, one or more conventions were set aside, but an even larger set of conventions remained in place. Innovation—like biblical creation—emerges when a small degree of chaos is introduced into a largely ordered and stable ecosystem. If the resulting turbulence is pleasing, the innovation is called a success, and it is continued. If the resulting turbulence is displeasing, we call that "disco," and we repent.
So the suggestion here is that you shouldn't break every rule at once, or all of the time. Just consider and reflect on what might happen if you break the rules.
1. You have heard it said, "You shall proclaim God's Word." I say...
There can be times when biblical preaching does not mean preaching on a biblical text. Yes, it sounds crazy. But a sermon series on the Apostle's Creed can be biblical preaching, since the Creed summarizes the biblical proclamation. Similarly, a sermon series on the liturgy (which is more than sung and prayed scripture) can be biblical preaching.
2. You have heard it said, "You shall not proclaim yourself." I say...
Sometimes you have to share your own faith. When I was on my seminary internship, a member of the church said, "We need to hear more about your faith and experience in your sermon. Not too much, but don't be afraid to let some of it in." The point is there is a degree of self-disclosure in preaching that is not only appropriate, but necessary. The best example I ever heard of this was when the organist died at the church I was serving, leaving a young boy motherless. The senior pastor spoke directly to the boy in his sermon and told about how hard it was on him when his own mother had died and left him motherless at an early age.
3. You have heard it said, "You shall not proclaim the season of the church year." I say...
There are times—even beyond Easter Sunday and Christmas Eve—when the messages of the assigned text (the text) and the church season (the context) are identical. Proclaiming the text in context means speaking directly to the marriage of the two. But really, preaching about the scribe Baruch on the occasion of Administrative Assistants' Week is going too far.
4. You have heard it said, "You shall have (at least) one point." I say...
Sometimes you can do more damage by having a point than by not having one. There are texts and moments in which the preacher might be best off admitting that he or she doesn't much like a text. Or understand it. Or hasn't finished wrestling with the text. Or finds it unsatisfying. Maybe, just maybe, once in a blue moon you could consider simply arguing with a text. This might be better than those sermons in which we simply pretend that the text says something other than what it does say.
5. You have heard it said, "You shall reflect on the implicit as well as explicit content of your preaching." I say...
There are rare moments when you will know that the implicit message that you send is the wrong one, but you have to send it anyway. A friend of mine was asked to preach at a wedding, but was told, "But we don't want you to talk about God." So, of course, she talked about God. There are times when you just have to plow ahead, and trust that the Holy Spirit will work salvation and healing.
6. You have heard it said, "You shall never be the hero of your own story." I say...
Sometimes, as Paul might have said, we have to speak as fools (see 2 Corinthians 11). There are times when the story is so perfect that you just have to use it. But be humble. Keep your head down. Cringe as you do it.
7. You have heard it said, "You shall love the sermon you preach with all your heart and have passion for it." I say...
Sometimes dialing it back a few notches will send a more powerful signal than will turning it the volume up to 11. As a whole, pastors still need to work not to send the message that they are preaching the life-giving, eternal Word of God, rather than the message that they are bored with their own sermon. But sometimes, you have to use your inside voice.
8. You have heard it said, "Your sermons shall have structure." I say...
See Commandment #9 and the accompanying explanation in Part 1 of this series.
9. You have heard it said, "You shall not structure every sermon the same way." I say...
How can you break a commandment that says not to do something the same way every time? Do you do it the same way every time just to break a rule? Hmmmm. "This is a head-aching problem," as my friend Hae Kwon Kim once said. But try this: if you are doing a seven-part sermon series, maybe having the same structure for those seven weeks would be a good thing.
10. You have heard it said, "You shall read a snippet of the text on which the sermon is based at the start of your sermon." I ask...
What would happen if instead of preaching about a lament psalm, you fashioned your entire sermon into a lament? What if your sermon became a prayer? Or a praise psalm? In some sense, this is what was happening twenty years ago when the idea of the "story sermon" became popular. Instead of an exposition of a text, the sermon became a story that in some way embodied the text's message.
Go, and do likewise.
Related Preaching Articles
By Tyler Scarlett on Feb 10, 2014
The sermon's not done until you sharpen the point. Here are four excellent ways to do it.
By Mark Dever on Jan 13, 2014
Here's why the pastor of Capitol Hill Baptist Church isn't interested in being cool.
By Chris Surber on Jan 18, 2014
A crowd of non-churchgoers just gathered in a church. Call me crazy. I don't know much. But perhaps you should tell them about Jesus?
By Sherman Cox on Jan 6, 2014
Sherman Cox takes up Will Willimon's challenge to preachers everywhere.