Summary: There is no "on the mountain" and "off the mountain" which can be explained by the virtue of equanimity.

Peter was talking, but yielded to the voice from heaven and listened.

“Listen to him" we hear from God the Father. Matthew 17:5

A woman named Barb tells about an incident that happened in her granddaughter’s kindergarten class. A boy in the class just wasn’t listening to his teacher. The teacher got fed up and said, “Since you don’t want to listen, you go sit at that table by yourself.” A few minutes passed, and Barb’s granddaughter raised her hand and said, “I don’t want to listen either. Can I sit with him?”

The word translated “obey” in the Old Testament means “to hear.”

1. Abram listened, who would later be called Abraham: God said, "Go forth from the land of your kinsfolk and from your father's house to a land that I will show you.”

God gave no details to Abram. He rarely does. It’s never as specific as we would like in our journey of faith and hope.

Hebrews 11:8 says, “By faith Abraham, …obeyed and went, even though he did not know where he was going.”

In Romans 4, Paul even refers to Abram (Abraham) as the “father of us all” through faith.

Abraham is mentioned in our First Reading because of his love for his son Isaac in Genesis 22:2, “Take your son, your only son, whom you love. “ It is the same Greek wording as the voice of the Father at Jesus’ transfiguration in Matthew 3:17, “This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased; listen to him."

[Source: “Isaac Transfigured: The Aqedah as Mashal Mattean Midrash,” by David Andrew Smith, the Catholic Biblical Journal, 84, 2022, pg. 69]

We are like Abram insofar as we don't know what's ahead for us in the next decades but we called to a trustful relationship with God.

2. The Catechism teaches that the transfiguration reveals that Jesus will have to go by the way of the cross at Jerusalem in order to "enter into his glory." #555

Elizabeth Palmer said, “You know that Transfiguration sermon that exhorts us to appreciate the [temporary] mountaintop beauty only for a moment before we descend into the world’s brokenness, joining Jesus in the way of suffering? I used to like hearing that sermon…

This year it’s the last thing I want to hear. I don’t need anyone to tell me to descend the mountain. I slid down months ago, and I haven’t been able to find my way back up.”

[Source: The Transfiguration sermon I need (Matthew 17:1-9), There is no "on the mountain" and "off the mountain" by Elizabeth Palmer February 24, 2017, The Christian Century]

Glory in Hebrew means "heavy, weighty, to be of great substance." God is a heavyweight! This is a weight that makes everything in life lighter.

As Palmer says, “it’s a heavy touch that acknowledges the suffering and sin intrinsic to the human condition--and yet, it is at the same time a healing touch that lets us know that we are not alone in the human condition. God is also in it with us, helping us bear the heaviness.”

The message is that Jesus is with us in both the glory and closeness and in our suffering. There is no "on the mountain" and "off the mountain" which can be explained by the virtue of equanimity.

For example, the Catholic Encyclopedia says that in the virtue of patience, we are disposed us to bear present evils with equanimity in such a way as not to be inordinately cast down by them.

Saint Jane Frances de Chantal “Above all we must love the good pleasure of God, accepting with equanimity things both agreeable and things painful, trusting everything to Him Who disposes of all things for the good of His children.”

And, in THE IMITATION OF CHRIST, in Book Three: Internal Consolation, number 5: The Wonderful Effect of Divine Love says,

“Love is an excellent thing, a very great blessing, indeed. It makes every difficulty easy, and bears all wrongs with equanimity. For it bears a burden without being weighted and renders sweet all that is bitter.”

St. Paul speaks of equanimity in Philippians 4:11-13, “I have learned to be content whatever the circumstances. I know what it is to be in need, and I know what it is to have plenty…. I can do all this through him who gives me strength.”

Rob Giannamore points out that it does not mean that we rest in a God who is going to make it all better. To the contrary, we rest in a God who suffers with us. [Source: Equanimity: Resting in God's Grace, by Rob Giannamore, 12/9/2020].

In sum, the virtue of equanimity is that, no matter what happens, it is going to be okay, maybe not the okay we wanted, but okay nonetheless.

[Source: Equanimity in the Buddhist and Christian Traditions, by Kathy Keary, March 29, 2021, Precious Blood Renewal Center, Missionaries of the Precious Blood Kansas City Province].

Another way to explain it is “apatheia” which is Greek work for “equanimity” in the Orthodox Church which has its root in apathy and means something like "a state of unaffectedness." When the prayerful person could reach that state of no longer being tied to the concerns of the world—the ups and downs of life—that person opened up the possibility of union with God.”

[Source: What ascetics have taught me about divine light, In the eastern tradition, theosis—union with God—is the goal of the Christian life, by Evan D. Garner, August 3, 2017].

However, equanimity is a virtue but it does not apply to active pursuits and it is not the same as Buddhist non-judgmental awareness. As Daniel Berrigan explains,

“…To the prophets of the Bible [equanimity]… would have been an absolutely foreign language and a foreign view of the human. The notion that one has to achieve peace of mind before stretching out one’s hand to one’s neighbor is a distortion of our human experience, and ultimately a dodge of our responsibility. Life is a rollercoaster, and one had better buckle one’s belt and take the trip. This focus on equanimity is actually a narrow-minded, selfish approach to reality dressed up within the language of spirituality.”

[Source: Daniel Berrigan, Essential Writings, by John Dear, Orbis Books, 2009].

The message for us is that an occasional celebration or reward is a good thing, but if our primary emotional coping mechanism leads us to sin or overindulgence we get stuck in an unhealthy cycle where the real feeling or problem is never addressed, e.g. "eat and numb" or "internet and numb." However, if we can be in our body without trying to fill low-level anxiety with some substance, we will find that it’s transformational to fill the empty spaces with the Cross that leads to Glory. How? We become progressively transfigured into Jesus Christ by realizing in us a fuller humanity.

St. Francis de Sales, “Keep your heart very wide to receive in it all sorts of crosses and resignations or abnegations, for the love of Him who has received so many of them for us.”

And, “Retire at various times into the solitude of your own heart, even while outwardly engaged in discussions or transactions with others, and talk to God.”

In conclusion, the words “Shine” and “Whine” are closer than we think because the “S” is just below the “W” the keyboard. And the “T” is not that far away, spelling “Thine” like in Proverbs 3:5, “Trust in the LORD with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.”

If we learn to rely on God’s love to sustain us, even as we are surrounded with other distractions, we will find unfailing support through the ups and downs of our lives.

Saint John Henry Newman noted that God inherently transforms us: “It is … the duty and the privilege of all disciples of our glorified Savior, to be exalted and transfigured with Him; to live in heaven in their thoughts, motives, aims, desires, likings, prayers, praises, intercessions, … to look like other [people], to be busy like other [people], to be passed over in the crowd…, or even to be scorned or oppressed,… as other(s) may be, but the while to have a secret channel of communication with the Most High, a gift the world knows not of; to have their life hid with Christ in God.”

Amen.