By Bob Hostetler on Mar 27, 2014
Bob Hostetler has a penetrating set of questions as part of his sermon prep. Perhaps they could help us all.
Years ago, when I began preaching, I developed a list of 20 questions to evaluate a sermon—before preaching it. It remains a mental checklist I use to this day:
1. Do I grab the listener’s attention as soon as I start speaking?
2. Does the talk start where people are (with their culture, needs, problems, issues, questions)?
3. Does it come on too strong, too fast?
4. Am I teaching the listener something he didn’t already know?
5. Am I communicating what God says, not my opinions?
6. Have I included an introduction of myself and words of welcome to the listener?
7. Have I included a re-statement somewhere in the talk of either Cobblestone's mission ("loving people into life-changing encounters with God") or distinctives (community-oriented, student-friendly, seeker-aware, outward-focused)?
8. Have I offered an elementary (but not condescending) explanation of the text that will help even a Bible newbie find it without feeling stupid (as well as avoidance of "church lingo" as much as possible)?
9. Have I revealed anything of myself in the talk without revealing anything inappropriate (so much the better if it’s vulnerable, self-effacing, and/or winsome)?
10. Do I interact with my listeners in the talk (e.g., mentioning people’s names, asking for responses, etc.)?
11. Have I included humor?
12. Am I being realistic instead of shallow? Will my listener believe I understand what he’s really going through?
13. Have I touched (not manipulated) my listener’s emotions?
14. Is my talk focused enough (instead of rambling)?
15. Have I played a part in meeting a felt need?
16. Is the “solution” I propose realistic? Life-related? Biblical?
17. Does the structure of my talk logically lead to the conclusion/application?
18. Have I left out anything important, crucial?
19. Have I given clear application for both a seeker and a Christian that answers the question, "OK, what am I supposed to do with this information now/today/this week?”
20. Have I made reference to how my listener can find further help (e.g., prayer counselors)?
A few things changed over the years. And if I were to revise it today, I would change a few things (e.g., adding some sort of reference to creating a visual, tactile, or other sensory impact, as I did in the sermon pictured above by wearing a straitjacket for much of the message). But overall, the questions still serve pretty well.
Related Preaching Articles
By Stuart Strachan Jr. on Aug 10, 2018
What are the most important things you need to let your guest preacher know before you head out of town?