-
Why Pastors Shouldn't Read Anonymous Notes
By David Whiting on Dec 24, 2021
Pastors and church leaders often receive anonymous comments, mysteriously appearing in the church office,the offering plate, or the “comments” section of the Sunday communication card.A few years ago, I stopped reading them. They don’t even get passed onto me. Asa church leader, I recommend that you do the same thing.
Pastors and church leaders often receive anonymous comments, mysteriously appearing in the church office, the offering plate, or the “comments” section of the Sunday communication card. A few years ago, I stopped reading them. They don’t even get passed onto me. As a church leader, I recommend that you do the same thing.
It is Larry Osborne who helped me think differently about not allowing anonymous voices to speak into decisions. In his excellent book, Sticky Teams, he has a rule: no name, no input.
Here are three reasons you shouldn’t read anonymous comments and notes.
1. Who they are matters.
We can’t know who wrote an anonymous note. Are they a leader of the church? How involved are they? How new are they? Are they even a Christian? If they are new, their comments still matter, but they carry a different weight than the person who serves weekly, is a faithful giver, and is committed to the mission of the church. It matters if the person is a weekly complainer or if this is the first thing that has bothered them in five years. It matters if they agree with the mission of the church or not. Do they even know the mission and vision of the church? Without that information, we can’t know if they can speak helpfully into the matter they have an opinion about. Who they are matters.
2. Difficult issues need a dialogue.
Church issues are almost never simple. They need dialogue. If someone wants to give genuine, helpful feedback, follow up questions are necessary. Knowing the struggle the leaders went through in deciding how loud the volume should be would be helpful. Knowing why we cancelled a recent youth trip can’t be understood well without hearing the reasons.
I pastored for almost twenty-five years, and rarely was there a complaint that wasn’t carefully thought through by the church leaders. If someone wanted to give feedback and dialogue about why we made the decisions we made, we were always willing to do that. But complex issues can’t be understood through an anonymous note, and meaningful dialogue that can result in changes can’t happen. Good church leaders make decisions through the filters of the mission, vision, and values of the church. An anonymous note doesn’t allow you to dialogue about those driving issues. Difficult issues need a dialogue not an anonymous comment.
3. Anonymous notes have an unusual power to intimidate and manipulate leaders.
It is easy to overreact to a negative anonymous note. Depending on the type of personality and leadership gifts you have, it can cause you to back away from something you shouldn’t back away from. Or because you can’t find out who wrote it, it may tempt you to address something publicly that should be addressed privately.
We also have a tendency to wonder or think that a group is larger than it is. It truly may be a single opinion – one voice among hundreds or thousands. Pastors, don’t give this power it doesn’t deserve.
There is one very important caveat to this: pastors must be approachable. You need to be sure that if someone gives an anonymous note, it isn’t because they have a reason to fear your reaction. Just because someone has a differing opinion doesn’t make them a “hater.” If we want people to give non-anonymous feedback, we should not label them as “difficult” or “always opposed to things” when they do give feedback.
Here is a lesson I continue to learn: If you gain a reputation of never receiving feedback well, then people will stop giving it. This requires humility and patience. When people approach you about difficulties and problems, you need to be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to become frustrated (James 1). And most strong leaders struggle with all three of those. If you don’t respond to pushback and questions well, people will either keep their mouth shut or write anonymous notes.
Here is my advice for how to handle anonymous comments.
1. Have a trusted person on your church staff receive all anonymous notes.
This person should clearly carry the DNA of the church and staff. They should have a bit of a thicker skin with a pastoral heart. They should read the notes and decide if they should be thrown away or, rarely, passed on to the church leaders and dialogued about.
2. Tell your church that you don’t read or pass on anonymous notes.
Making this a publicly known fact takes away the power of anonymity and helps them consider if they are willing to meet face-to-face or at least sign their name to discuss and own their feedback.
Pastors, do not indiscriminately read anonymous feedback, comments, or complaints. They will hold you hostage from doing what you should do, capture too much of your attention, have a voice they shouldn’t have, or provide you frustration you don’t need. For your sanity, the unity of the church, and for the sake of speaking the truth in love, don’t read anonymous notes!
Related Preaching Articles
-
The Barnabas Factor: Five Practices To Help You Find More Leaders
By Larry Osborne on Jan 30, 2024
Larry Osborne explains "the Barnabas Factor" in successfully building church teams.
-
Getting An Approachability Checkup
By Ken Sande on Feb 28, 2018
An expert in conflict management, Ken Sande brings his expertise to pastors and leaders to help them relate better with their congregation, co-workers, and families.
-
10 Suggestions For The Shepherd Of A Stagnant Flock
By Joe Mckeever on Dec 13, 2022
Non-growing churches are not healthy, at least in some significant ways. Joe McKeever gives his input to help revive a church that seems to have "plateaued."
-
5 Top Priorities For Increasing Your Church
By Charles Arn on Mar 1, 2018
Whether you’re in a church of 20 or 20,000, these principles will help you to invest the talents God has given to your church.
-
Top 5 Lessons From Dr. Adrian Rogers' Preaching Ministry
By James O. Davis on Mar 6, 2020
James O. Davis shares powerful principles from the life and ministry of the great preacher, Dr. Adrian Rogers.
-
52 Quotes For This Generation Of Church Leaders
By Brad Lomenick on Apr 15, 2020
52 insightful quotes from Brad Lomenick that pertain to the preaching and pastoral audience.
-
6 Surprising Leadership Principles From The Bible
By Tom Harper on Mar 19, 2018
Tom Harper traveled through the whole of Scripture looking for one fresh leadership principle in every book ... learn what he found.
-
3 Unspoken Promises People Expect Leaders To Keep
By Hal Seed on Mar 7, 2020
Every Christian leader I know wrestles with leading with diligence. Become aware of the promises you make as a leader, especially the ones you might not know about.